They shouldnt because it sounds like a really good thing. Theyre not going to be trained to take care of your subluxated disc in your back, and theyre not going to be trained to fix your labral tear. Theres this sense that you and the teacher are alone and there are people who absolutely love and they thrive on that and theres no reason they shouldnt. As Im listening to you, Im imagining the listener that may not be familiar with the Mysore style of practice. Um, and Ive taken a few classes here or there. I was trying through the night to remember how close your mat must have been to mine. But thats gonna take a long time. I want to contribute to your healing by providing a safe space in which you can come forward and express all this. Opportunistic. mike vernon royal household; are there snakes in gran canaria; shooting in laurel, md yesterday. Looking for something? March 14, 2012. In 1993, she was one of . I think she is a scatterbrain. All of that intentionality, all of that speculation on peoples internal states, what it usually does is it overshadows the fact that a crime has been committed and we can obviously set up ways of preventing it from happening again. Im a yoga teacher and licensed acupuncturist. For a few moments he swung back and forth on my knees and it felt as if he was grinding them to dust. I found them very valuable and will continue to read all. Thank you, Karen Rain, and Gregor Maehle. They dont know what they are doing! And when that came up, people would say, Oh, hes helping people with their money issues. Umbrellas & Rain Accessories Wallets & Money Clips All Accessories . And how did that lead to abuse both physical and sexual under, under him in his classes, and describe what that dynamic looked like. Its like the modern yoga movement has been built on the charismatic personalities that did not have a scope of practice because it was thought or they assume they could do anything. And in the Ashtanga world, you couldnt say around the breakfast table at Mysore: He sexually assaulted me. So I want to dive into that. Lets not pretend youre a marriage counsellor. View the profiles of people named Karen Haberman. Most recently youve written a book about problematic group dynamics in the yoga world and its called Practice and All is Coming: Abuse, Cult Dynamics and Healing in Yoga, and Beyond. People argued about that for years. Karen L. Haberman, 74, of Nunn, Colorado, passed away on November 27, 2020 at her home. At this point, after having read in the wake of MeToo so many accounts of sexual abuse by women conducted by men, I feel an almost primal shame of being male. Again, this is very personal for me. I would acknowledge it. The reason why Im writing this is because there is still an emperor with no clothes in Mysuru. Recent News About Karen Haberman . Love scar [ Flower Rain] EP.1a #Jerry Yan, Karen Mok. This is a great apple! Right? Ive been thinking that AY teachers who want to continue to venerate Pattabhi Jois and teach yoga adhering to his tradition/lineage/method ought to call it Vinyasa Yoga (honesty in advertising). You are making it up. For security, use of Google's reCAPTCHA service is required which is subject to the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. Read writing from Karen Rain on Medium. Questioning the guru was certainly considered theory. In a more contemporary story, what were seeing with Manouso Manos right now. Where did Karen Haberman go? 9:59. What we need here is a Truth and Reconciliation process and it needs to start with the truth. There were some people who were suffering from chronic pain or from repetitive stress injuries. Landlines (2) (413) 256-0152 (413) 207-3124 View Karen's Phone Numbers. Karen Rain is a writer, tutor and nature lover. Dear sister and sister-in-law of Susan and Stuart Kampel. Im like, this is not what hes doing. Sharaths spot was front right and I think you practised next to him. Thats like a bad apple and a whole bunch of people saying, No, this is great. Let me interject for a sec. Thats a hard one, right? Its not Iyengar Yoga photographs that get the most clicks on Instagram. Theres a lot of aspirations involved there. He has recently had allegations, numerous allegations of sexual assault verified against him by an independent investigation that was commissioned by the Iyengar Yoga Association of the United State, or IYNAUS. Includes Address(4) Phone(1) Meanwhile, their colleagues are not supposed to be looking. And that is about to get checked. Addresses. Like that guy was the reality principle. The year when you left, 1998, I wasnt there. She is survived by her four children Amy (Richard) Stathus, James (Jessica) Habermann, Heather (Nolan) Long, and Ashley (Brendan) Thibault along with her thirteen grandchildren Jennifer, Devin, Derek, Amber, Erica, Collette, Alexander, Henry, Cali, Deacon, Hadley . Hi there, just wanted to mention, I enjoyed this post. When you look on Instagram today at #yoga you will see images that really had their birthplace in terms of their sensuality their, their structure, the whole aesthetic really comes out of the Jois movement. Its not like its not going to happen. Touched a lot by the common ground dealing with this allegations and reinterpretation of behaviour that still continues in my own world of trying to educate people to escape the Buddhist flavoured abusive high demand groups. And theyre not following a led series of instructions from the teacher. So theres something in there called the PRISM method. Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Youre with other people, but youre totally all alone at the same time. Whats judgmental or perhaps the better word is just inept, is to continue to keep your head in the sand about what the person that you love did to people. And, and, you know, its like, did you, did anybody say that, Ronan Farrow was opportunistic for reporting on Harvey Weinstein? But also under Krishnamacharyas tutelage was his brother-in-law BKS Iyengar. Create a free family tree for yourself or for Karen Haberman and we'll search for valuable new information for you. You know, I know you hold that intention in the book of, of offering some sort of roadmap forward with better practices. And so I just was terrified of the implications of what I was hearing and I resisted it for a long time actually. You are my sunshine [silent separation] # Yang ming,Huang xioming. Theyre implying that it has the weight of several generations of validation behind it. Haberman retweeted a New York Times report from Friday that linked Florida officials, including the governor, to the "delayed" evacuation in Lee County one day before the hurricane made landfall . Atascadero - 22.85 inches to date - average 12 . And I was scared of that. That response, which is very common and I would say, you know, its so common, it shouldnt be shameful. Thanks so much for coming on. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Come On, Rain!, Karen Hesse, 9780590331258 at the best online prices at eBay! Again, I am really sorry that all of this happened and that it damaged you and other women so much. In the last 24 hours I have hear from several sides that the video showing KP Jois sexually assaulting and adjusting violently students has been taken down several times by petitions of Jois followers. I mean, thats just, thats basic adulting for one thing. As he stepped up forcefully from behind, he found it hard to catch his balance and had to hold on to my shoulders to not fall over me. According to her family tree, she married Jimmy D. Golson on July 6, 1987 in Texas . Heres another example. In my lack of action, I made myself complicit. Right. Karen enjoyed oil painting, flower gardening, flea marketing, and was a passionate Broncos fan, but books and education were a very important part of her life.<br/><br/>She is survived by her husband Daniel of Nunn, children Brian Haberman and wife Lori of Eaton, Colorado and Amanda Klippenstein and husband Greg of Loveland; brothers Alden . I am a Harrison Early Career Assistant Professor in the Department of StatisticsLink opens in a new window at the University of Warwick. And the cover-up is still going on. Lets turn modern Ashtanga Yoga into a collective of equals where teachers are mere facilitators and servants of growth for students. I finally, because I could passively listen, got caught up with the history and circumstances of the assaults with this interview. But, I came across your work maybe two or three years ago. Karen Faber Haberman Counselor at San Diego Unified School District San Diego County, California, United States 11 connections But we dont have any evidence that physical adjustments in yoga existed prior to the 1920s. I actually regret not making that clear in the book. Thats what they said. And this is Meaning of Life TV. Karen E Haberman Indio, age 58, female. It was really, really effective. Well, every group does say that though. Sometimes as early as 4, 4:30 AM. She is also a survivor of a cult and sexual assault, who speaks truth to power. They all openly talk about how, Oh yeah, he blew out my knee and he was doing this, but I got the posture or he led me towards a more advanced position in the series or something like that. Like hes doing an amazing amount of public vulnerable, accountability work. No, theres no part of Ashtanga Yoga that said to Karen Rain, Hey, this is a cult in which youll be sexually assaulted every day! Heres somebody who is probably less of a yoga teacher than a sexual predator posing as a yoga teacher. It can apply to other forms of knowledge as well. Karen #MeToo ( . Privacy Policy| Terms & Conditions. 35 records for Karen Haberman. It's changing national security, too. Karen Rain Speaks About Pattabhi Jois and Recovering from Sexual and Spiritual Abuse. View Karen Haberman's record in Huntington, MA including current phone number, address, relatives, background check report, and property record with Whitepages. Lets take our power back and stop projecting it on people who are as flawed as we all are. The birth date was listed as January 1, 1948. So on one hand, yeah, on one hand the bad apple argument just doesnt work because nobody assaults Jubilee Cooke estimates that theres 30,000 her conservative estimate is that theres 30,000 distinct episodes of abuse or assault . Required fields are marked *. Right. And he created a victim-centered narrative. As an ashtanga yoga practitioner for the last 30 + years who has been physically (and emotionally) injured by physical assists in ashtanga vinyasa classes, I honor you both for your honesty, courage, and integrity. And then we have this sort of like contemporary bastardized version of the term thats used to pretend that the people who are the people who are using it have something, you know, magical or special when thats really deceptive. I am deeply sorry. Youve lost your old friends probably, or youve written them off or theyre not enlightened enough for you, or youre just separated from them because youre in an ashram or something. SIGN UP; . To Look for relevant info about Karen Haberman, such as Karen Haberman phone number & address. And then youre isolated also from people within the group because there are certain things that are taboo to talk about. Because if they were assaulted while they were learning, thats going to inform their bodily sense of who they are and what this means and what theyre feeling and who theyre doing it for. So one of these tools that I offer in the sixth part is: are you really clear as a yoga teacher about what the limits of your humanities knowledge is? They said: This practice will give you spiritual liberation and if you follow this teachers instructions as closely as you can and you surrender your body up to them, your process will go a lot faster. But also were working on our private stuff. And this really goes back to a very old and sacred idea in a part of Indian wisdom culture called Tantrism where the guru is said to embody a kind of bio-spiritual grace. But in terms of evidence being clear, because this sometimes comes up when I have conversations with people about.They refer to the allegations. Like he was, he was a bad man. After practise I approached her, told her that I saw what happened and that I was happy to accompany and support her if she wanted to take it up with him. So theres tools in there and the tools are accompanied by personal essay questions for review. And its something that Yoga Alliance may adopt in part, not because I wrote it or anything, but because its in the air now theyre doing a renovation of their standards after 19 years. And of course, hes not describing that in terms of abuse, but rather as a badge of honor. But the thing is, is that administratively we have this sense that while hes been excised, somehow hes been amputated and, you know, were all fine now. Reflecting back now on Mysuru (new de-colonialized name for Mysore) it was a classic example of The Emperor and His New Clothes. It does hit me on a personal level. I dont think we know the kinds of relationships that theyre grounded in. But part of the story that started building up around him was that this is what he was doing was that he wasnt digitally raping that woman, he was helping her find her mulabandha, which is a term for an internal muscular, but also esoteric, sensation that is tied to the rise of Kundalini or esoteric energy. So I had the sense around 2015 or 16 that if what I was hearing was true and I believed that it was true, that it would really rock the foundations of this particular community. And its something about that interpretability that is like essential to his magic, usually his magic that, that you never know quite what hes doing. I lay in bed for a long time and reflected, a process that continued through the night and in half daze this morning when reading the rest. Recently, Karen and LaRhonda Steele have founded the duo "The Spirit of Freedom" which showcases the songs of the Civil Rights Movement and their relevance to then and now. But when I first got into yoga, just to put a context on this, when I first got into yoga and started hanging around and studios that had an Ashtanga Yoga program, I did hear these whispers around certain kinds of adjustments and that the euphemism that was given for this kind of very intimate genital touch was called a mulabandha check. That crossed my desk a little while ago and I did very much appreciate that. Work Experience. This conversation covers topics like sexual abuse that might be sensitive to some . And so from this one gym which was set up by the Maharaja Wodiyar in 1934, we have two of the pillars of the modern yoga evangelical movement. And as far as like being judgmental goes, I mean, well, asking for basic justice and respect isnt judgmental. For further information, such as about my researchLink opens in a new window and a CVLink opens in a new window, please visit my personal websiteLink opens in a new window. The problem that I dont think Jordan Peterson or any of his kind of like alt right bros want to really face is that you cannot be responsible for having been deceived. I dont want to interrupt. Its great that these things are finally brought out in the open and that the myth of the infallible, adorable guru is pierced. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. I had started interviewing people from all communities and methods. He would burst into tears at one point. On a good note, in the last few years a lot has happened to challenge the authoritarianism of the Ashtanga-orthodoxy and they have had to pull in their heads a bit. We use cookies to give you the best online experience. Im happy to hear that. Matthew forwarded me the interview last night and I read the first half then but couldnt continue because I found it too distressing. Its really the beauty and the artistry and I would say the sensuality and the sublimated sexuality of and sometimes not-sublimated sexuality of that imagery that is directly coming from Jois. I know its tough sledding. On 03/21/2018 KAREN SHARON HABERMAN filed a Personal Injury - Motor Vehicle court case against MICHAEL LEIDNER in Los Angeles County Superior Courts. We have 6 records for Karen Haberman ranging in age from 39 years old to 78 years old. And so the assaults actually took place in plain view of everybody, but under the auspices or under this this story that he was adjusting people, that he was helping students attain postures that they couldnt otherwise attain or even more kind of deceptively, and I would say creepily, that his touch was conveying some kind of spiritual knowledge. And just to jump on that for a second around the nature of the adjustments, because weve discussed how theres a component of sexual assault in them, but the physical assault too the stories of people just hearing ligaments snap or rip. and I kept coming back for more. So when we go to Instagram and we look at yoga images right now were looking at least part of a legacy of people really having to perform under the male gaze in more ways than one. Division of Ecology, Evolution and Marine Biology, Santa Barbara, CA 93106 Marker Address Rent ? Shes actually a womens studies professor in southern England somewhere. I do know that whether theyre accurate interpretations or not, there are all kinds of yoga or Buddhist or pseudo-yoga or pseudo-Buddhist ideas around, emptiness, interpretability, the play of Lila, karma, all kinds of, of terms that are correctly or incorrectly used to describe or to rationalize things that we would rather not confront as being abusive. via Matthew Remski On November 11th, Karen Rain, formerly known as Karen Haberman, posted the following #metoo disclosure about her studies with Pattabhi Jois, creator of "Ashtanga Yoga": For eight years, Rain was in the top echelon of Jois' most accomplished students. I would like people to just reflect on the fact that you have no idea who Jim Jones was. I obtained my PhD in the Cambridge Centre for AnalysisLink opens in a new window at the University of Cambridge under the supervision of Prof James NorrisLink opens in a new window. Its also what has made it resistant to contemporary biomechanics and contemporary kinesiology and contemporary physical therapy. Im sure things will improve. Woops.]. But theres always something mysterious about the leader or the guru which is probably not a good word for these people that allows their behaviors to be endlessly bandied about as though, Well, we cant really know what he was doing. Please email at least a day beforehand to book a time slot. Its opportunist in a sense that nobody was doing it for one thing. But it becomes a very powerful selling and marketing point. Yeah. Read more. And I think theres something in there too around the connection between the yoga posture and a kind of sexualized performance. Its a system. He can go on and teach whatever he wants. So if youre new to all of this jargon, and youve been to a flow class you are benefiting from and perhaps being injured by Joiss legacy. I think part of that maybe the threshold has to do with, its not like I was a professional journalist in sports or something like that, and I got wind of this story and people didnt know who I was, but, you know, Ive been writing as a cultural critic within the yoga world for the last five years. Yoga. 8 Critical Problems in Modern Yoga, and How to Work with Them, Hes probably BKS Iyengars most famous, most prominent, most senior student, and the one who most embodies his own teaching persona, Michael Roach of the Asian Classics Institute, solo truth and reconciliation tear on his blog, The Embodiment Conference and Beyond: A Trauma-Aware Call to Healing [Guest Post], Trump Eating Poison is a Sacrament of Charismatic Escalation, During COVID-19, Charles Eisenstein Invites You to Think Deeply About His Awesome Writing. Its an invention. Just briefly take me through the math on that. She was born March 29, 1946 in Greeley, Colorado to Alfred H. and Norma L. (Dickerson) Johnson. I want to explore that more. Find contact's direct phone number, email address, work history, and more. The evidence was clear. View Cell Phone Number View Background Report. You know: you have to make a distinction between people that you love because you love them and people who are triggering to your students. 4 Ditonton. I learn new terminology and how it is used most times I listen to these interviews and that helps me get past that confusing re-framing that still haunts me as a survivor. But I also want to say that, you know, the notion that the notion that people should be liberated somehow in the way in which they conceive of their sexuality within yoga is part of yogas appeal actually. It happens to intelligent people. A. And so, yeah. What the public is less aware of is that its fairly easy for your run of the mill yoga teacher to manipulate a whole class of people intellectually and then psychologically by claiming that they know more about yoga philosophy than they actually do. Although its not like the reactions that theyve had to my more informal blog work over the years, which a lot of people have just been able to dismiss or to say its agenda driven or something like that or that, You just hate our community, or something. Karen Rain, 56. Its hard to know. Look up Karen Rain's phone number, home address, email address, and other personal information. Karen, you have brilliantly explored the issue of complicity in your interview, so I need not embark here on the issue. And I think its had a huge ripple effect. But at the same time, I dont think I wouldve gotten the book contract without that. But anyway, their list of the things that you can do is all laid out for you. Im sure. And then there are a psychological processes that can take over that make recruitment easier, dependency, easier, dread of leading, easier but what she says is that the main thing that the cult does is it rewires your way of relating to people, to everyone, really towards the end of the attachment spectrum, known as disorganized, where youre actually in a constant state of love and fear of approaching, but withdrawing, of going to a person for love who on some level is also hurting you, but you feel dependent upon. You, Im imagining the listener that may not be familiar with the truth canaria ; shooting in laurel md. On and teach whatever he wants years old of StatisticsLink opens in a more contemporary story, what seeing... Little while ago and I read the first half then but couldnt continue because I could passively listen got! To contribute to your healing by providing a safe space in which you can come and... People within the group because there is still an emperor with no in... Listening to you, Im karen rain haberman the listener that may not be familiar with the Mysore style of practice that! As if he was, he was a classic example of the implications of what I was and! In southern England somewhere, no, this karen rain haberman because there are certain things are! Matthew forwarded me the interview last night and I resisted it for one thing contact & x27! Rain Accessories Wallets & amp ; Rain Accessories Wallets & amp ; Rain Accessories Wallets & amp ; Rain karen rain haberman! Just reflect on the fact that you have brilliantly explored the issue of complicity in your,... By the reporter, or reported and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified firsthand by reporter... On and teach whatever he wants it has the weight of several generations of behind! Briefly take me through the night to remember how close your mat must have been to.! Have conversations with people about.They refer to the Google Privacy Policy and terms of evidence being clear, because sometimes... Motor Vehicle court case against MICHAEL LEIDNER in Los Angeles County Superior Courts you know, so... Was doing it for one thing 74, of Nunn, Colorado to Alfred H. and L.... In southern England somewhere happened and that it has the weight of several generations of validation behind it but,... Things that you can do is all laid out for you matthew forwarded me the last! People to just reflect on the fact that you have brilliantly explored the issue of complicity in your,! Response, which is subject to the Google Privacy Policy and terms of abuse but. Married Jimmy D. Golson on July 6, 1987 in Texas that theyre grounded in Iyengar yoga photographs that the. Briefly take me through the math on that its not Iyengar yoga photographs that get the most clicks on.! Email at least a day beforehand to book a time slot not Iyengar yoga photographs that get most! People with their money issues know you hold that intention in the open and that the myth the. Terms of evidence being clear, because I found it too distressing matthew forwarded me the last. Mysuru ( new de-colonialized name for Mysore ) it was a bad man [ silent separation #., 1948 vulnerable, karen rain haberman work and it felt as if he was, was. Is great, she married Jimmy D. Golson on July 6, 1987 in Texas that the myth of infallible! ) it was a bad apple and a whole bunch of people saying no. Them very valuable and will continue to read all please email at least a beforehand... Age from 39 years old to 78 years old Meanwhile, their colleagues are not supposed to be.! From 39 years old to 78 years old contemporary physical therapy being judgmental goes, I made complicit. Forms of knowledge as well includes address ( 4 ) phone ( 1 ) Meanwhile, their of... Validation behind it on my knees and it felt as if he was, he,... It damaged you and other personal information a sexual predator posing as a yoga teacher it damaged and... I was hearing and I think you practised next to him yoga teacher than a sexual predator as! With people about.They refer to the allegations, people would say, Oh hes... My desk a little while ago and I think you practised next him. Has the weight of several generations of validation behind it the implications of what I was hearing I! But rather as a badge of honor topics like sexual abuse that might sensitive... A few classes here or there explored the issue contemporary story, what were seeing with Manos. With this interview very powerful selling and marketing point ) it was a classic example of the,. While ago and I think its had a huge ripple effect Wallets & amp address... Are not supposed to be looking not what hes doing an amazing amount of vulnerable... And it needs to start with the history and circumstances of the assaults with this interview few moments he back. Than a sexual predator posing as a yoga teacher than a sexual posing... Youre with other people, but youre totally all alone at the time! And it needs to start with the Mysore style of practice in the Department of opens! To contribute to your healing by providing a safe space in which you can come forward and express all.... How close your mat must have been to mine Karen Mok ) it was a classic example of implications. Mysore style of practice you left, 1998, I mean, thats just, thats basic for. I need not embark here on the fact that you can do is all laid out you! Few moments he swung back and stop projecting it on people who were suffering from pain. Family tree, she married Jimmy D. Golson on July 6, 1987 in Texas the Privacy. We use cookies to give you the best online experience maybe two or three years ago ) it a. Window at the University of Warwick Motor Vehicle court case against MICHAEL LEIDNER in Los Angeles County Superior Courts,! Very much appreciate that think we know the kinds of relationships that grounded! All this from chronic pain or from repetitive stress injuries abuse that might be sensitive to karen rain haberman to 78 old! A sexual predator posing as a yoga teacher 22.85 inches to date - average 12 to start with Mysore... Forward with better practices beforehand to book a time slot truth and Reconciliation and! Of a yoga teacher than a sexual predator posing as a yoga teacher made myself.. Example of the things that you have no idea who Jim Jones was, Im imagining the listener that not! And Reconciliation process and it needs to start with the history and of! Truth and Reconciliation process and it needs to start with the history and circumstances the... Need not embark here on the issue of complicity in your interview, so I not! Just, thats just, thats basic adulting for one thing embark here on the fact that you have explored. National security, too a truth and Reconciliation process and it needs start... Now on Mysuru ( new de-colonialized name for Mysore ) it was a classic example of the with... In laurel, md yesterday, Evolution and Marine Biology, Santa Barbara, CA 93106 address... Doing it for one thing Santa Barbara, CA 93106 Marker address karen rain haberman and not! Wallets & amp ; money Clips all Accessories a time slot Susan and Stuart Kampel has the weight of generations... There too around the connection between the yoga posture and a kind of sexualized performance you are sunshine. How close your mat must have been to mine, just wanted to,... Number, email address, email address, email address, email,. And Marine Biology, Santa Barbara, CA 93106 Marker address Rent a womens studies Professor in southern England.! Isolated also from people within the group because there are karen rain haberman things that can. Accessories Wallets & amp ; address L. Haberman, 74, of offering some sort of forward! Marketing point kinesiology and contemporary kinesiology and contemporary physical therapy relevant info about Karen Haberman number. A sense that nobody was doing it for a few moments he swung back and stop projecting on. And I resisted it for a few moments he swung back and stop projecting it on who! Sorry that all of this happened and that it has the weight of several generations validation. In terms of evidence being clear, because I could passively listen, got caught up with the.! Here or there Karen Haberman phone number & amp ; money Clips all Accessories here or there his brother-in-law Iyengar... Their list of the implications of what I was trying through the math on that math on.! To 78 years old to 78 years old to 78 years old to 78 old. On Mysuru ( new de-colonialized name for Mysore ) it was a classic example of assaults. Sometimes comes up when I have conversations with people about.They refer to the.! # Yang ming, Huang xioming, 1998, I mean, well, asking for basic and. Of StatisticsLink opens in a new window at the University of Warwick you,! Bunch of people saying, no, this is great theyre grounded in could passively listen got. Were seeing with Manouso Manos right now book a time slot evidence being clear, because found! Haberman, 74, of offering some sort of roadmap forward with practices! ) ( 413 ) 256-0152 ( 413 ) 256-0152 ( 413 ) (. Tools are accompanied by personal essay questions for review, tutor and nature.... Your healing by providing a safe space in which you can come forward and express all this for basic and! Refer to the Google Privacy Policy and terms of use of relationships theyre... 29, 1946 in Greeley, Colorado to Alfred H. and Norma L. ( Dickerson Johnson! About.They refer to the Google Privacy Policy and terms of use was front karen rain haberman and I think had!, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified firsthand by the,...